|
Melco Audiophile NAS
|
|
12-12-2014, 18:46
Post: #4
|
|||
|
|||
RE: Melco Audiophile NAS
(12-12-2014 16:14)DavidHB Wrote: @simoncn Thanks for this thoughtful and constructive response. I was concerned that my post might elicit the kind of responses typical of the Linn forum, and I'm thankful this hasn't happened (yet). Quote:I am intrigued as to how you came by this piece of kit and why you chose to test it. Information on the web is remarkably sparse. The post to which you linked is a (rather informative) product announcement, but I can't find anyone who is actually selling the item as yet. It has been loaned to me by Melco. If you want to buy one, a web search tells me that it is available from Analogue Seduction. Quote:That apart, your post is of particular interest both because it comes from you and because of the way in which you have been able to narrow down the range of possible causes of what you have observed. By now, you must know as much as anyone about the specifics of running music server software on NAS hardware. Moreover, in this forum and elsewhere, you have always taken an open-minded but sceptical approach on the question of whether network components can affect sound quality. So your observations in this instance were, as you implied in your post, counter-intuitive, and therefore worth taking seriously. My approach to this is scientific, by which I mean formulating a theory, trying an experiment to validate the theory, observing the results and then trying to understand any observed differences from what the theory would predict. My first 12 experiments with different server hardware didn't show any significant difference, as expected from my theory. I was very surprised by the result from experiment number 13 and I am now trying to understand what is causing this. Quote:Was the "very noticeable change in the clarity and transparency of the music" you observed in any way comparable to the change in SQ you experience as consequence of transcoding your files to WAV24? The reason I ask is that increased clarity and transparency is what I get from transcoding. If improving the network configuration can add more of the same, that is potentially rather good news. It is very similar but even more noticeable. For example, the first piece in Monterverdi's Vespers (a favourite test track of mine) has powerful choral singing with some trumpets playing. On poor equipment, it isn't easy to hear the trumpets in the "wall of sound". On my pre-Melco setup, the trumpets are clearly audible and blend in with the choral singing. With the Melco, the trumpets are as clear as if they were playing as solo instruments. Quote:If the change is the result of the configuration of the network components rather than the working of the NAS as such, I certainly agree with you that we are unlikely to be seeing any change in the actual digital content delivered to the player. The only other variable I am aware of that can affect SQ is the timing of that delivery, in other words the dreaded jitter. I am told by Melco that the improvements are caused by reduced jitter in sending the network data, opto-isolation to prevent transmission of electrical noise and a better power supply to prevent common mode interference. My understanding of these technical details is quite limited and I won't attempt to expand on what I have been told. Quote:There is also the fact that you are using a Linn player. AFAIK, Linn ties the DAC in its players to its own clock when playing network streams, and so does not use the clock data provided by the source. (This, I had always understood, was the reason why FLAC files ripped from a CD sound better on my player than the same CD played on my CD player used only as a transport, and so delivering the CD data to the same DAC as the network stream.) If opto-isolating the network connection as you have described improves the performance even of the Linn DAC/clock combination, that is a remarkable result. Would the result be the same if the opto-isolation were at the player end, one wonders. Like you, I had thought that the Linn player would be more or less immune from interference by anything at the other end of the Ethernet cable and it was a great surprise that I could hear such a big difference. Quote:I look forward to any further information you can glean on this interesting subject. In the meantime, I shall remain as sceptical as ever on the issue of whether network cables can affect SQ ... Since you happen to mention cables, I will report one more observation. The Melco player came with a Melco cable whch was claimed to improve sound quality. For the Melco to Linn connection, I have compared the Melco cable with a normal Cat 5 cable and there is a small but noticeable improvment when using the Melco cable. This improvement is much less than the improvement from connecting the Linn via the Melco NAS. |
|||
|
« Next Oldest | Next Newest »
|
User(s) browsing this thread: 2 Guest(s)

Search
Member List
Calendar
Help



